TOP TOOL
Guidelines for Using TOP Tool
A practical guide for teaching staff to aid with a common framework and criteria for best practice.
Aims
- To involve and get feedback from teachers and adult students during Job Shadowing.
- To know how to use our toolkit: observation grids and peers agreement and feedback sheets.
- To collect useful data leading to an improvement of the tool in future next projects.
Tools
- Teachers Grid (Google Form, printable. Only available in English – users might translate it locally, if needed):
Due to the great diversity of our educational contexts (reflecting variety in the adult field) we agreed that this grid has to be as exhaustive as possible. We want to guide teachers with an explicit and precise formulation of different elements of observation, covering all approaches and skills that we agreed our own language students need to successfully learn.
In order to facilitate the use of the grid:- Teaching practices to be observed will be defined each time by each teacher during the pre-observation stage and will be limited to those items that might help professional development of both parties. Teachers do not need to provide answers to all categories or statements.
- Each criteria/practice will be observed and quantified on a scale (1 to 4). The field N/A will be used only if the relative criteria is not observable due to the nature of the lesson.
- The “open” text field should be used to report meaningful examples.
- Students Grid (one common paper version, each item in ENG, ITA, ESP)
We produced a simplified grid, due to: diversity of context, limited time of observation and possible different profiles (and linguistic barriers). - Sheets: peers preliminary agreement & feedback
They are typically part of an individual and private experience, to ensure that this process is only aimed at professional development and doesn’t imply or involve any evaluation by others (superiors, school managers).
Required steps
- Educational institutions should involve their teacher in a general information session on:
- TOP project and Job Shadowing principles: (source: Padlet). As discussed during the Kick Off Meetings and Training Course, introducing teachers to the idea of Peer Observation can be beneficial if the teachers are first explicitly made aware of the benefits of this professional development practice and are then asked to look at a few myths surrounding the whole idea of observing peers (most of all, the idea that it is an evaluation). The participating teachers can then be encouraged to break these myths through an understanding of the benefits of Job Shadowing. Remind teachers involved in Peer Observation that they might work in pairs to ensure mutual trust.
- Peer observations planning/recommendations:
- at least two different observations per teacher, on different content/classes
- at least two different students involved in observation
- avoid planning internal observation sessions at the beginning of a new course, or during exams
- Teachers Observations will be managed in three phases:
- Before the lesson: agreement. A previous meeting should be held to agree on dates and content – observation focus and selection of areas of interest from the grid.
- During the lesson: observation. Each teacher should take notes (on the printed version/on paper/digitally) to be able to fill the GForm Grid the same day.
- After the lesson: submit feedback to peers, in a private meeting (using shared guidelines for giving feedback).
- Students will also submit their feedback to their teacher about the same lessons, using the specific grid.
